Share this photo on Twitter Share this photo on Facebook

The choice: Color or black/white version

Posted by
Willem (Noord-Scharwoude, Netherlands) on 8 November 2018 in Business & Industry and Portfolio.

The choice for the aminus3 viewers:
Color or black/white version (see yesterday) .

NIKON D3 13 second F/8.0 ISO 100 70 mm

Martine Girard from France

Jolie photo qui montre bien la pollution.

8 Nov 2018 5:11am

By Marie from Entre montagnes et Bretagne, France

I have no preference. The color version was beautiful and the black and white version has more class but both are superb

8 Nov 2018 5:55am

@By Marie: Thanks Marie

Gérard Flayol from Allauch, France

This version in B&W shows more the pollution idea.

8 Nov 2018 6:17am

@Gérard Flayol: Thanks Gérard.

Pascale MD from Occitanie, France

C'est très beau aussi en noir et blanc et du coup il m'est bien difficile de choisir entre les deux.
Bonne journée Willem

8 Nov 2018 6:23am

@Pascale MD: Merci pour votre commentaire.

yoshimiparis from France

Je suis allée voir la prise de vue en couleur mais je préfère nettement le monochrome.
La pollution est une évidence avec les usines, mais votre image est puissante, très claire et dramatique en même temps.

8 Nov 2018 6:36am

@yoshimiparis: Merci pour votre commentaire.

Peter from Obdam, Netherlands

Ik ga voor deze, een toppertje!

8 Nov 2018 6:58am

jpla from St Barthélémy, France

une grosse préférence pour le N&B

8 Nov 2018 7:07am

@jpla: Merci pour votre choix.

Ana Lúcia from Leiria, Portugal

When an image is strong! it is also beautiful in B / W and color!

8 Nov 2018 7:22am

@Ana Lúcia: Thanks Ana.

Ralf Kesper from Fröndenberg, Germany

Amazing capture. Much better in b/w. 5*****

8 Nov 2018 7:23am

@Ralf Kesper: Thanks Ralf.

Anna Cherer from LA ROCHELLE, France

I prefer this BW version, excellent !

8 Nov 2018 7:41am

@Anna Cherer: Merci Anna.

mo.langel from Courtelary, Switzerland

Superb BW! Excellent capture!

8 Nov 2018 8:14am

Martine Libouton from Bousval, Belgium

J'aime beaucoup les deux versions ! Magnifique !

8 Nov 2018 9:08am

@Martine Libouton: Thanks Martine.

Shaun from Massachusetts, United States

I think far better in B/W. A superb industrial image. 5*

8 Nov 2018 10:14am

@Shaun: Thanks Shaun.

Remus from Portugal

I prefer the color version.

8 Nov 2018 11:28am

@Remus: Thanks Remus.

Mhelene from Villiers-sur-Marne, France

Superb in B&W ! I prefer it !

8 Nov 2018 11:49am

@Mhelene: Merci Mhelene.

beach from Oshawa, Ontario, Canada

You know what? I like this better than the colour shot. The smoke is far more dramatic in this one. Bravo!

8 Nov 2018 12:05pm

@beach: Thanks Beach.

Hiro from Mukoh Kyoto-pref., Japan

I like the both !

8 Nov 2018 12:11pm

@Hiro: Thanks Hiro.

Existence Artistique from Angers, France

Bel effet

8 Nov 2018 1:27pm

Dreams come treu from Utrecht, Netherlands


8 Nov 2018 1:48pm

@Dreams come treu: Dankjewel.

tataray from Charentes-Poitou, France

Superbe effet. belle luminosité.

8 Nov 2018 2:31pm

Ruthiebear from Titusville, NJ, United States

I prefer this dynamic B&W

8 Nov 2018 2:57pm

@Ruthiebear: Thanks Ruthie.

Hanry from Castricum, Netherlands

Dit is ook een sterk beeld, lastig om te zeggen welke keuze te maken. Ik heb een lichte voorkeur voor de kleurversie, maar eigenlijk zijn beide beelden even sterk!

8 Nov 2018 3:27pm

@Hanry: Dankje Hanry.

klaas from Netherlands

Mooie zwart/wit foto.!!!!!!

8 Nov 2018 3:51pm

Lewis from Harns, Netherlands

Beide zijn heel mooi, deze is iets ‘krachtiger’.

8 Nov 2018 6:50pm

@Lewis: Dank Lewis.

Darkelf Photography from Perth, Australia

Monochrome suits this industrial landscape superbly and especially with the contrast provided by the dark night sky.

9 Nov 2018 3:26am

Nina from Hamburg, Germany

great in black and white ... but I also like the color version, light and golden tones are particularly beautiful

9 Nov 2018 4:54am

@Nina: Thanks Nina.

Marjolein from Westvoorne, Netherlands

Heerlijk gezegd vind ik de gekleurde mooier

9 Nov 2018 10:09pm

@Marjolein: Dankjewel.

omid from mashhad, Iran

Wonderful !!!!!!!!!!!!

10 Nov 2018 11:39am

omar from Kunduz, Afghanistan

Incredible picture! Great work

3 Jan 2019 5:42pm

This image has been featured in 1 Remix collection.

Favourite founds by Ralf Kesper